I just stumbled across the pinterest page of a gentleman who worked on props for Star Trek (2009), Will Olsen: https://www.pinterest.com/willolsen/work-pictures/
This film has a couple of unseen or barely seen props, notably the Kelvin's phaser and communicator. To add to that list, apparently Klingon tricorders were made for the movie! I don't recall seeing these on screen. @NickyTea you are more well-versed in JJ movie knowledge; do you recognize these?
Echoes of the design are visible in the medical tricorder from Into Darkness... The lower end also brings to mind the STIII Klingon communicator.
Here are photos that Mr. Olsen posted:
A dozen were made:
There was also this photo which he labeled as "Romulan phasers" from 2009 which are also unfamiliar: